Say "Yes" to AIE

Advice for
Design Professionals
("What am I doing!?")

Survival Guide Part 1:
You have good company

Part 2:
Be yourself

Part 3:
Do something!

Part 4:
Learn their names

Part 5:
Repeat yourself


 

Survival Guide, Part 5:
Repeat Yourself, Repeat Yourself

Less is more. The trick here is to approach your central goals from a whole bunch of different directions and activities.

When you're developing vocabulary, have the kids look at examples in slides, draw them, cut them out of magazines for a Bingo game and hunt for them on a neighborhood walk.

If you're talking about building materials, have the kids handle samples, describe them, find them throughout the school and learn where they come from and how they're transformed. And so on.

In general, they've never heard or talked about these things before, so you need to repeat and reinforce a coherent body of information rather than jump all over the place with new concepts.

Remember, too, that there are six whole days of other school subjects, basketball, arguments with friends, visits to relatives and zillions of other experiences between your visits. The same goes for you. You'll need ways to link your sessions so that you can keep track of what's going on!

Use the classroom... Label the elements.

Label the materials...
Show them ways to estimate the dimensions using paces, or lying on the floor as human rulers.
Talk about the mix of natural and artificial light.
Look out the window and look for building types, interesting parts of the skyline, energy systems and patterns.
Show them how their view is represented on a map of the city.
Help them figure out just how far they can see.
Have them trace images right onto the window with erasable markers, or onto acetate sheets.

... and the school.
Take them into some of the specialized rooms to talk about their functions and how they are expressed through design, materials, size, lighting and acoustics. Again, get the students to figure it out and have them make notes or drawings or rubbings of what they find. (They're analyzing now.)
Show them how to trace the utility systems all the way into the basement until you get to the furnace and water heater, pointing out ducts, pipes, wires and fuse boxes along the way until they can do it by themselves. (You might mention off-handedly that they will be instantly electrocuted or horribly burned if they touch any of these things.) Studies of energy systems can occupy the whole eight weeks!
Go outside and study the exterior of the building for geometric shapes, patterns, ornament, materials, handicap access, landscape... you know. It's all right there.

Get them out of the classroom and the school.

Whatever topic it is you're dealing with will surely exist in some way in the school's neighborhood. Get 'em out there, but have them ready before you step out the door, because once you're outside, all hell breaks loose. They straggle. They can't hear you. They start shoving each other. They can't get their jackets zipped, etc.

Don't go out with the vague idea that you're going to discuss things on the way.
  Break into two or three groups as your team allows. Don't walk too fast. Don't try to do too much.
Arm them with clipboards and check-off sheets.
Make the trip a treasure hunt or a bingo game; they go nuts when they find things.
Take rubbings.
Roll up paper into spyglasses to zero in on details.
If there's a park or campus where they can all sit, let them try "on-site" drawings, and have some way for them to elaborate on their pictures when they get back inside by adding color or ornamentation or landscape elements. Otherwise, they'll forget that they did them.

Get them to draw, but jazz it up

Some kids will happily draw pictures all day, but many are shockingly inhibited, especially after about the third grade.

Many children are so naive about architectural possibilites that they "just can't think of anything" -- and they really can't. Many children are so inexperienced with art materials (this will break your heart) that they balk when given opportunities to draw and color, and seem to have no imagination at all.

These students are finished with their drawings in about 45 seconds, having put on their papers a box with a triangle on the top and a chimney sticking out to the side and two symmetrically placed windows with curtains and flower boxes -- a house that no one in the universe has ever seen.

Now is the time you're glad that your students have loads of images to pick from, right up there on the poster or right here in these magazines and drawings. Tell them that it's perfectly all right to copy. They think, because they've been told it, that "copying is bad." You probably think the same thing. But in this case, it's "borrowing ideas" and all artists do it.

If they want you to draw some part of the picture for them, go ahead, but on another piece of paper that they can then transfer. Talk them through these crises: "Well, you'll need a door, right? How about a real fancy one, or a real big one like in this photograph?" You can't overcome all of the obstacles that may be inhibiting some of the students, but by giving them choices, you can pull many of them into a realm that they can handle.

If drawing just bombs out, drop it and switch to collage the next week. Just plain drawing, actually, can get boring -- the ultimate sin.

You can breathe life into drawing projects in lots of ways, using trace paper, cut-outs, applique and plastic overlays. You can string their pictures together into a long streetscape, and have them add detail and color in this new and more unusual format (plus then the other kids will get mad at them if they don't help). You can have them do shared drawings, or draw an image dictated to them and so on.

It's actually easier for many of them to draw when they have specific parameters that save them from the hostile glare of the blank paper. (You've maybe felt that panic yourself once or twice? Share that with them, that even professional-type adults have trouble with this stuff because it really is hard and complicated, isn't it?)

Get them to build things, and leave your expectations behind

If you think you've been amazed so far by what the kids come up with, wait until they get into the third dimension. They'll try anything, using whatever you give them in completely inappropriate ways that will charm you silly.

Unhappily, however, as in the case with drawing skills, you must be prepared for students who are inexperienced with craft supplies or who go blank for ideas unless they can choose from _____________________________________ (Complete the sentence. If you don't know by now, copy off your partner.)

Along with the many visual images you've plastered all over the class by now (yes, that is the correct answer), give them lots of junk to use and pretend it's a lesson in recycling: corks, bottle caps, toilet paper tubes, sandpaper, whatever.

Be advised, however, of some hard truths:
  • Latex glue takes forever to dry.
And you are the one who ends up standing there holding the pieces together for 15 minutes, unable to move. So: go into building sessions equipped with bobby pins and your own personal dispenser of scotch tape which no one else is allowed to borrow so that you can race from desk to desk clamping pieces together and taping them for temporary support.
  • Beware of the tape monster.
Students of all ages are extremely naive about structural properties -- not only those of concrete and steel but also those of cardboard and pipe cleaners. Their solution to supporting a shoebox with stilts cut (unevenly) from paper straws is to get hold of the only roll of masking tape in the whole school and wind all of it around and around everything until it only falls over a little bit. (This is why you don't let them get near the tape in your pocket.)
  
It pays to give them some sort of guidance about support and balance before they get their hands on anything, because once they get going, they won't listen to reason. Basically, they need to be told that big heavy stuff needs to go at the bottom and little tiny things that crush easily should probably be somewhere further up. (It may hit you that you can start your eight weeks right here and spend the rest of the time expanding on structure and materials.)
  
It's really hard to get a piece of cardboard to stand up all by itself. But the kids will kill themselves trying to get their first wall up this way, and will start looking around for the tape. Don't let them get stymied by falling into this trap. Show them beforehand how to avoid it: Show them how to tape two pieces together or score a piece and fold it so that the angle will hold up the walls. Or, let them use shoeboxes, or let them make each wall flat to be raised later. (Hey, a way to explain what an elevation is!)
  
This, again, is a perfect introduction into structural concepts, and it can be used as the first problem if that's the direction you want to take.
  
The kids are NOT to use matte knives. Some older students, maybe, with the teacher's permission and under close adult scrutiny. Better to assume that if you invite them to score cardboard or make openings that you're going to do the cutting based on their marks. Here's where teamwork counts; one of you will likely be completely tied up for a while cutting windows and skylights and whatnot. There's no way around this; school scissors are usually so crummy that they can barely cut paper.
  
Reserve sparkly things for the end. Kids are like magpies. They go for the glitter. Anything that shines or glistens will be used up immediately and nothing else will do after that.

A very important note: Although many of our eight week sessions culminate or center around a construction project, there is no "must" about it.

Your final presentation at the wrap-up meeting can be a play, a dance, the record of an oral history developed around neighborhood residents, a series of two-dimensional projects, or photographs of the kids planting perennials around the school.

Think of your presentation at the wrap-up as a summary of the process you went through.

Help them make their stuff look nice.

Kids are embarrassed by ratty-looking products, and they may expose their levels of self-esteem by the way they treat their own work. Do whatever you can to help them keep tidy without interfering.

We know it's a fine line, and maybe not always possible, but let them erase their mistakes or cut off the part they don't like. Complain to them about crumpled-up drawings or paper ripped out of spiral notebooks with ragged edges. Treat their work with respect and insist that they do, too.

Praise their efforts all the time.
Praise their efforts all the time.
Praise their efforts all the time.
Praise your own efforts all the time.

As you can no doubt tell by now, there's no way to predict exactly what's going to happen for you over the next two months.

You'll probably have some bumpy times, and you'll probably start to have weird waking dreams as memories of your own education begin to erupt, and you'll probably wish that you'd had somebody like you coming into your classroom when you were a kid.

You'll maybe have the experience that many of our people have described: That by opening yourself up about your work to children and young adults, you find that your ideas crystallize, and your work takes on a whole new dimension of meaning, since, in a sort of dizzying way, these kids really are your clients, aren't they? They're the very creatures you ultimately design for: people.

And because they're young and unpolished, they'll ask you blunt questions and tell you when they can't make any sense out of your answer. So, tell them when you don't know; tell them when there aren't yes-or-no answers; and encourage them that there is plenty of room in all kinds of trades, professions and avocations where they can take their rightful places in this vast discourse.

And when it all gets to be too much, just relax and enjoy yourself, and bask in the knowledge that many, many people are extremely grateful to you for helping with this amazing venture.

This essay was prepared by Marcy Abhau, AIE Education Specialist.

 


   AIE 
  Home Page |  Give Us Feedback | Contact 
  Us! | Suggest a Resource

This site was made possible through the generous support of The Foundation for Architecture,
WHYY, the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, and the National Endowment for the Arts.

© Copyright 2001